Mapping Metaphor with the Historical Thesaurus

The Metaphor Map of English shows the metaphorical links which have been identified between different areas of meaning. These links can be from the Anglo-Saxon period right up to the present day so the map covers 1300 years of the English language.

Metaphor map showing the connections between 'Strength' and other categories, with the category 'Emotion' expanded
Metaphor map showing the connections between 'Strength' and other categories, with the category 'Emotion' expanded

Mapping Metaphor uses the database of the Historical Thesaurus to survey the workings of metaphor in English over thirteen centuries. Over the past 30 years, it has become clear that metaphor is not simply a literary phenomenon; metaphorical thinking underlies the way we make sense of the world conceptually. When we talk about "a healthy economy" or "a clear argument" we are using expressions that imply the mapping of one domain of experience (e.g. medicine, sight) onto another (e.g. finance, perception). When we describe an argument in terms of warfare or destruction ("he demolished my case"), we may be saying something about the society we live in. The study of metaphor is therefore of vital interest to scholars in many fields, including linguists and psychologists, as well as to scholars of literature.

Underlying the data and visualisations in the resource is a great deal of research. The evidence for the metaphorical connections presented is made as transparent as possible through links to the Historical Thesaurus of English online for each ‘example of metaphor’ and from there into the Oxford English Dictionary online. In order to identify areas of meaning which overlapped metaphorically, it was first important to identify areas which shared words. For this purpose, the Historical Thesaurus was divided into 415 distinct semantic areas (e.g. Light, Fear, Weapons and Armour, etc.), which are grouped into the 37 areas of experience corresponding to the second level of the Historical Thesaurus hierarchy (e.g. Matter, Emotion, Armed Hostility, etc.) and the three top-level groupings (The External World, The Mental World and The Social World). These 415 categories were then mapped against each other – all items of vocabulary in one category (the ‘start category’) were checked computationally with all the other categories. Where our queries found identical word forms then these were pulled out along with their sense and date information.

Once all of the overlapping vocabulary from the ‘start category’ was identified in every other category then it was analysed manually by a member of the Mapping Metaphor team. We were looking for lexical evidence that one area of meaning was being understood in terms of another, or had been in the past. A large percentage of the overlap reflected processes other than metaphor, such as homonymy and non-metaphorical polysemy. However, there were well over 10,000 connections in which we found evidence of metaphor. We were particularly interested in finding clusters of metaphorical overlap which provided evidence of a systematic connection between two semantic categories. For example, because of the conceptual link between weather and anger we find many of the same words in our categories of Weather and Anger, such as storm, tornado, wind and fulminate. If this was the case then we labelled this connection as ‘Strong’, while if we found a small number of lexical metaphorical connections between two categories but little evidence of a systematic connection then we labelled this as ‘Weak’. The initial coding was then checked by another member of the team and each link was examined separately in each direction (e.g. from Light to Cleverness and again from Cleverness to Light). The final stage of analysis was to decide on a final code based on the accumulated coding, comments from coders and the pinpointing of evidence from specific word senses in the Historical Thesaurus instantiating the metaphorical link. If we could not find specific evidence of metaphorical transfer in the overlapping words between two categories then the link was not regarded as ‘Metaphor’.

Project website: https://mappingmetaphor.arts.gla.ac.uk/


Main contact: Wendy Anderson

Developer: Brian Aitken

Start year: 2012

End year: 2014

Funded by: AHRC

Subject area: English Language & Linguistics

Keywords: History of EnglishMetaphorVisualisation

Record last updated 2019-12-11